Skip to content
Commonwealth of Reason
decision:is-gas-cheaper-than-under-biden

Is Gas Cheaper Now Than Under Biden?

Every factual sentence carries assertions checked against the recorded evidence: references must resolve, figures and quotations must be in the cited passage, arithmetic must reproduce, and an independent reviewer must approve the wording. Automated validation says whether the narration is ready for human editorial review; it does not establish truth.

Validation
passed (revision 2)
Runtime
658 words, about 5 min at 150 wpm
Assertions
34 of 34 verified
Issues
0 blocking, 0 warnings
Storyboard
25 scenes, 5:04 (ok)
Model
claude-opus-5-5

Open a sentence to see its assertions, their status and the passages behind them. Sentences without a marker make no factual claim.

Hook

In January 2026, a gallon of regular gas cost well under its average for Joe Biden's presidency. s01 verified

verified s01.a The national monthly average for regular gasoline in January 2026 was well below its February 2021 to January 2025 average.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…
By spring, it cost well over it. s02 verified

verified s02.a In spring 2026 the national monthly average for regular gasoline was well above its February 2021 to January 2025 average.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.95).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly wrong 95%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…
So is gas cheaper now than under Biden? That depends on what you mean by now.

Question-1

President Trump made the case at a cabinet meeting: "It was $4 and $5 for a gallon of gas", he said, "and now it's probably 225". s04 verified

verified s04.a Trump said gas had been $4 and $5 a gallon.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement Fact check: Trump says food and gas prices are down It was $4 and $5 for a gallon of gas. Think of that for ga gasoline. And now it's probably 225.

verified s04.b Trump said gas was now probably 225.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement Fact check: Trump says food and gas prices are down It was $4 and $5 for a gallon of gas. Think of that for ga gasoline. And now it's probably 225.
By this spring, CBS News was reporting pump prices "at their highest point since mid-2022". s05 verified

verified s05.a CBS News reported that gas prices were at their highest point since mid-2022.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement Trump makes new promises on gas prices as Iran war reaches 60-day mark they are now at their highest point since mid-2022
Here is the record to check them against: the Energy Information Administration's national monthly average for regular gas, in dollars not adjusted for inflation.
From February 2021 through January 2025, it came to $3.46 a gallon, with a peak of $4.93 in June 2022. s07 verified

verified s07.a The national monthly average for regular gasoline averaged $3.46 a gallon over February 2021 to January 2025.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

Calculation: 3.461 = 3.46

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L562024 3.075 3.212 3.426 3.611 3.603 3.455 3.484 3.389 3.214 3.137 3.053 3.018 2025 3.076 3.121 3.096 3.171 3.150 3.150 3.125 3.133 3.166 3.060 3.050 2.894 2026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = …

verified s07.b Its highest month in that period was June 2022, at $4.93 a gallon.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

Calculation: 4.929 = 4.93

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L562024 3.075 3.212 3.426 3.611 3.603 3.455 3.484 3.389 3.214 3.137 3.053 3.018 2025 3.076 3.121 3.096 3.171 3.150 3.150 3.125 3.133 3.166 3.060 3.050 2.894 2026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = …
In 2025 the lowest month, December, came to $2.89, well above the president's guess. s08 verified

verified s08.b The lowest 2025 monthly average was December, at $2.89 a gallon.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.92).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

Calculation: 2.894 = 2.89

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 92%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 41-L562021 2.334 2.501 2.810 2.858 2.985 3.064 3.136 3.158 3.175 3.291 3.395 3.307 2022 3.315 3.517 4.222 4.109 4.444 4.929 4.559 3.975 3.700 3.815 3.685 3.210 2023 3.339 3.389 3.422 3.603 3.555 3.571 3.597 3.840 3.836 3.613 3.318 3.134 2024 3.07…
Every month of 2025 was below the Biden-era average, but about level with the last months of his term. s09 verified

verified s09.a Every 2025 monthly average for regular gasoline was below the February 2021 to January 2025 average, but about level with October 2024 to January 2025.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L562024 3.075 3.212 3.426 3.611 3.603 3.455 3.484 3.389 3.214 3.137 3.053 3.018 2025 3.076 3.121 3.096 3.171 3.150 3.150 3.125 3.133 3.166 3.060 3.050 2.894 2026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = …
Then the weekly price jumped, from $3.02 in the first week of March 2026 to $4.50 by mid-May. s10 verified

verified s10.a Weekly regular gasoline was $3.02 a gallon in the first week of March 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA regular gasoline, weekly: Weekly regular gasoline stepped from 3.015 (03/02/2026) to 3.502 (03/09) and 3.990 (03/30), reaching 4.500 by 05/11, a 54% rise over the Feb 2026 pre-war monthly baseline of 2.908, in the same weeks WTI jumped from 64.51 (Feb) to 91.38 (Mar); the timing fits the conflict as the cause, though a price series alone cannot rule out other drivers. Add the qualification: th…

Calculation: 3.015 = 3.02

  • qualifies EIA regular gasoline, weekly right 70%, partial EIA regular gasoline, weekly, lines 467-L4702026-Feb 02/02 2.867 02/09 2.902 02/16 2.924 02/23 2.937 2026-Mar 03/02 3.015 03/09 3.502 03/16 3.720 03/23 3.961 03/30 3.990 2026-Apr 04/06 4.120 04/13 4.123 04/20 4.044 04/27 4.123 2026-May 05/04 4.452 05/11 4.500 05/18 4.490 05/25 4.475

verified s10.c Weekly regular gasoline reached $4.50 a gallon by mid-May 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA regular gasoline, weekly: Weekly regular gasoline stepped from 3.015 (03/02/2026) to 3.502 (03/09) and 3.990 (03/30), reaching 4.500 by 05/11, a 54% rise over the Feb 2026 pre-war monthly baseline of 2.908, in the same weeks WTI jumped from 64.51 (Feb) to 91.38 (Mar); the timing fits the conflict as the cause, though a price series alone cannot rule out other drivers. Add the qualification: th…

Calculation: 4.500 = 4.50

  • qualifies EIA regular gasoline, weekly right 70%, partial EIA regular gasoline, weekly, lines 467-L4702026-Feb 02/02 2.867 02/09 2.902 02/16 2.924 02/23 2.937 2026-Mar 03/02 3.015 03/09 3.502 03/16 3.720 03/23 3.961 03/30 3.990 2026-Apr 04/06 4.120 04/13 4.123 04/20 4.044 04/27 4.123 2026-May 05/04 4.452 05/11 4.500 05/18 4.490 05/25 4.475
News reports tied the jump to the war with Iran: MS NOW said gas was "up by well over a dollar since the war started", and NBC News put it plainly: "it's the war in Iran that's largely causing fuel prices to rise". s11 verified

verified s11.a MS NOW said gas was up by well over a dollar since the war started.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 qualifying, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement ‘Simply wrong’: GOP lawmakers caught LYING about gas prices up by well over a dollar since the war started.

verified s11.b NBC News said the war in Iran is largely causing fuel prices to rise.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 qualifying, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement Trump faces ‘bipartisan pushback’ on diesel deal with Russia as he tries to lower prices IT'S THE WAR IN IRAN THAT'S LARGELY CAUSING FUEL PRICES TO RISE.
West Texas Intermediate crude oil jumped in the same month, from $64.51 a barrel in February to $91.38 in March. s12 verified

verified s12.a WTI crude averaged $64.51 a barrel in February 2026 and $91.38 in March 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA WTI crude, monthly: Pump prices tracked crude under both administrations: WTI 91.64 to 114.84 (Feb-Jun 2022) with gasoline 3.517 to 4.929, WTI 64.51 to 102.13 (Feb-May 2026) with gasoline 2.908 to 4.479, and the 2025 decline of WTI to 57.97 with gasoline easing to 2.894; co-movement supports the claim but cannot exclude policy effects on crude itself. Add the qualification: the evidence suppor…

  • qualifies EIA WTI crude, monthly right 60%, partial EIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L522021 52.00 59.04 62.33 61.72 65.17 71.38 72.49 67.73 71.65 81.48 79.15 71.71 2022 83.22 91.64 108.50 101.78 109.55 114.84 101.62 93.67 84.26 87.55 84.37 76.44 2023 78.12 76.83 73.28 79.45 71.58 70.25 76.07 81.39 89.43 85.64 77.69 71.90 2024…
Those reports tie the rise to the war; the price record shows when prices jumped, but on its own it cannot rule out other causes. s13 verified

verified s13.a The weekly price record shows when gasoline prices jumped in March 2026, but a price series alone cannot rule out causes other than the Iran conflict.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA regular gasoline, weekly: Weekly regular gasoline stepped from 3.015 (03/02/2026) to 3.502 (03/09) and 3.990 (03/30), reaching 4.500 by 05/11, a 54% rise over the Feb 2026 pre-war monthly baseline of 2.908, in the same weeks WTI jumped from 64.51 (Feb) to 91.38 (Mar); the timing fits the conflict as the cause, though a price series alone cannot rule out other drivers. "causes" is stronger than…

  • qualifies EIA regular gasoline, weekly right 70%, partial EIA regular gasoline, weekly, lines 467-L4702026-Feb 02/02 2.867 02/09 2.902 02/16 2.924 02/23 2.937 2026-Mar 03/02 3.015 03/09 3.502 03/16 3.720 03/23 3.961 03/30 3.990 2026-Apr 04/06 4.120 04/13 4.123 04/20 4.044 04/27 4.123 2026-May 05/04 4.452 05/11 4.500 05/18 4.490 05/25 4.475
In October, President Trump made the same kind of claim about crude: "Oil was higher under Biden than it is under Trump". s14 verified

verified s14.a Trump said oil was higher under Biden than it is under Trump.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 contradicting, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement President Trump Holds Press Gaggle Before Flight to Kalispell, Montana Rally - 10/14/26 Oil was higher under Biden than it is under Trump.
In September, the latest month in the EIA's crude table, it averaged $97 a barrel, higher than in every month of Biden's term except March through July 2022. s15 verified

verified s15.a WTI crude averaged $97 a barrel in September 2026, the latest month in the table, higher than every month from February 2021 to January 2025 except March to July 2022.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

Calculation: 97.31 = 97

  • supports EIA WTI crude, monthly wrong 90%, direct EIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L522021 52.00 59.04 62.33 61.72 65.17 71.38 72.49 67.73 71.65 81.48 79.15 71.71 2022 83.22 91.64 108.50 101.78 109.55 114.84 101.62 93.67 84.26 87.55 84.37 76.44 2023 78.12 76.83 73.28 79.45 71.58 70.25 76.07 81.39 89.43 85.64 77.69 71.90 2024…
Gas, meanwhile, averaged $4.36 a gallon in September. s16 verified

verified s16.a The national monthly average for regular gasoline was $4.36 a gallon in September 2026.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.95).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

Calculation: 4.355 = 4.36

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly wrong 95%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…
Put the lines side by side and the pump price has moved with crude under both presidents: both peaked in June 2022, both ended 2025 lower than they started it, and both jumped in March 2026. s17 verified

verified s17.a WTI crude peaked in June 2022, was lower in December 2025 than in January 2025, and jumped in March 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA WTI crude, monthly: Pump prices tracked crude under both administrations: WTI 91.64 to 114.84 (Feb-Jun 2022) with gasoline 3.517 to 4.929, WTI 64.51 to 102.13 (Feb-May 2026) with gasoline 2.908 to 4.479, and the 2025 decline of WTI to 57.97 with gasoline easing to 2.894; co-movement supports the claim but cannot exclude policy effects on crude itself. Add the qualification: the evidence suppor…

  • qualifies EIA WTI crude, monthly right 60%, partial EIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L522021 52.00 59.04 62.33 61.72 65.17 71.38 72.49 67.73 71.65 81.48 79.15 71.71 2022 83.22 91.64 108.50 101.78 109.55 114.84 101.62 93.67 84.26 87.55 84.37 76.44 2023 78.12 76.83 73.28 79.45 71.58 70.25 76.07 81.39 89.43 85.64 77.69 71.90 2024…

verified s17.b Regular gasoline peaked in June 2022, was lower in December 2025 than in January 2025, and jumped in March 2026.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L562024 3.075 3.212 3.426 3.611 3.603 3.455 3.484 3.389 3.214 3.137 3.053 3.018 2025 3.076 3.121 3.096 3.171 3.150 3.150 3.125 3.133 3.166 3.060 3.050 2.894 2026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = …
That fits what a guest on PBS NewsHour said, that the pump price "is set in a global market"; but prices moving together cannot show that policy played no part, since policy can move crude itself. s18 verified

verified s18.a A guest on PBS NewsHour said the price paid at the pump is set in a global market.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 qualifying, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement How the diesel price spike is rippling through nearly every part of the economy the price of diesel we pay at the pump for gasoline for that matter, is set in a global market

verified s18.b Pump prices moving with crude supports the view that gasoline follows the global oil market, but co-movement cannot show that policy played no part, since policy can move crude itself.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: EIA WTI crude, monthly: Pump prices tracked crude under both administrations: WTI 91.64 to 114.84 (Feb-Jun 2022) with gasoline 3.517 to 4.929, WTI 64.51 to 102.13 (Feb-May 2026) with gasoline 2.908 to 4.479, and the 2025 decline of WTI to 57.97 with gasoline easing to 2.894; co-movement supports the claim but cannot exclude policy effects on crude itself. Add the qualification: the evidence suppor…

  • qualifies EIA WTI crude, monthly right 60%, partial EIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L522021 52.00 59.04 62.33 61.72 65.17 71.38 72.49 67.73 71.65 81.48 79.15 71.71 2022 83.22 91.64 108.50 101.78 109.55 114.84 101.62 93.67 84.26 87.55 84.37 76.44 2023 78.12 76.83 73.28 79.45 71.58 70.25 76.07 81.39 89.43 85.64 77.69 71.90 2024…
So whether gas is cheaper than under Biden depends on the month: yes, against his term's average, through February 2026; no, in every month since March, though still short of that 2022 peak. s19 verified

verified s19.a Regular gasoline was below its February 2021 to January 2025 average in January and February 2026.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.9).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly right 90%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…

verified s19.b Regular gasoline was above its February 2021 to January 2025 average in every month from March to September 2026, and below the June 2022 peak.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.95).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly wrong 95%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…
But gas is one price among many. What about prices overall?

Question-2

The channel Squirrelly Economics put the comparison this way: "Prices rose about 21% over Biden's 4 years". s21 verified

verified s21.a Squirrelly Economics said prices rose about 21% over Biden's 4 years.

supported (approved): no direct support, 1 qualifying, 1 source statement.

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • statement Trump's Mystery 1.7% Inflation Number... Explained With Squirrels Prices rose about 21% over Biden's 4 years. In the head nut's first 20 months this term, about 5.4.
The Bureau of Labor Statistics' consumer price index agrees: it rose 21.4 percent from January 2021 to January 2025. s22 verified

verified s22.a The CPI-U rose 21.4 percent from January 2021 to January 2025.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

Calculation: (317.671 / 261.582 - 1) * 100 = 21.4

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…
From January 2025 to September 2026, the latest month, it rose 6.1 percent. s23 verified

verified s23.a The CPI-U rose 6.1 percent from January 2025 to September 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

Calculation: (336.94 / 317.671 - 1) * 100 = 6.1

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…
But that sets a full term against one still under way, over a much shorter stretch. s24 verified

verified s24.a The January 2025 to September 2026 period is much shorter than the January 2021 to January 2025 period.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…
Over stretches as long as this one so far, at each end of Biden's term, prices rose 13.5 percent at the start, January 2021 to September 2022, and 4.5 percent at the end, May 2023 to January 2025. s25 verified

verified s25.a The CPI-U rose 13.5 percent from January 2021 to September 2022.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

Calculation: (296.808 / 261.582 - 1) * 100 = 13.5

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…

verified s25.b The CPI-U rose 4.5 percent from May 2023 to January 2025.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

Calculation: (317.671 / 304.127 - 1) * 100 = 4.5

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…
And the count is still running: the year-on-year rate climbed from 2.4 percent in February 2026 to 3.7 percent in September, the same months gas jumped. s26 verified

verified s26.a The CPI-U 12-month change was 2.4 percent in February 2026 and 3.7 percent in September 2026.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…

verified s26.b Regular gasoline was higher in every month from March to September 2026 than in February 2026.

supported (approved): 1 supporting (1 independent, strongest 0.95).

info wording: Wording differs from the canonical claim; the reviewer confirms the passages entail it.

  • supports EIA regular gasoline, monthly wrong 95%, direct EIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L562026 2.809 2.908 3.638 4.103 4.479 4.050 3.932 4.058 4.355 - = No Data Reported; -- = Not Applicable; NA = Not Available; W = Withheld to avoid disclosure of individual company data. Release Date: 10/14/2026 DERIVED COMPARISONS (computed 20…
So prices have risen more slowly this term than across Biden's term as a whole, though faster than in his last stretch, and by a smaller margin than the totals suggest; and the index cannot say how much of either rise any president caused. s27 verified

verified s27.a The CPI-U rose at a slower annualized pace from January 2025 to September 2026 than from January 2021 to January 2025, by a smaller gap than the cumulative totals show.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…

verified s27.b The CPI-U rose more from January 2025 to September 2026 than from May 2023 to January 2025.

qualified (qualify): no direct support, 1 qualifying.

warning needs-qualification: BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026: CPI-U rose 21.4% from January 2021 to January 2025 (261.582 to 317.671) and 6.1% from January 2025 to September 2026 (to 336.94); the cumulative figure is far smaller, but it covers 20 months versus 48, and annualized the pace is 3.6% versus 5.0%, a smaller gap. Add the qualification: the evidence supports a narrower or weaker statement.

  • qualifies BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026 partly 80%, direct BLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L992021-01 261.582 0.4 1.4 2021-02 263.014 0.5 1.7 2021-03 264.877 0.7 2.6 2021-04 267.054 0.8 4.2 2021-05 269.195 0.8 5.0 2021-06 271.696 0.9 5.4 2021-07 273.003 0.5 5.4 2021-08 273.567 0.2 5.3 2021-09 274.31 0.3 5.4 2021-10 276.589 0.8 6.2 2…

Close

Both answers turned on the calendar: which month counts as now, and how long a stretch you measure. So when someone tells you prices are lower, ask: compared with when, and over how long? And when the pump price moves, check what crude oil did that month.

25 scenes, 5:04 at 150 words per minute including pauses. Narration is copied from the script; every chart value and on-screen citation is checked against a passage.

1. sc01 · 0:00 to 0:08 data-chart

In January 2026, a gallon of regular gas cost well under its average for Joe Biden's presidency.

Visual. Two price tiles side by side: the Biden-era average on the left in neutral, January 2026 on the right landing in green on "well under".

Biden-era average, Feb 2021 to Jan 2025$3.4613.461usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L56
January 2026$2.8092.809usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L56

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

2. sc02 · 0:08 to 0:10 data-chart

By spring, it cost well over it.

Visual. Same two-tile layout; the January tile is replaced by May 2026, landing in red on "well over".

Biden-era average, Feb 2021 to Jan 2025$3.4613.461usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L56
May 2026$4.4794.479usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L56

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

3. sc03 · 0:10 to 0:18 typography

So is gas cheaper now than under Biden? That depends on what you mean by now.

Visual. The question types on, large and centred; "now" holds and turns amber on "what you mean by now".

On screen. Is gas cheaper now than under Biden?

4. sc04 · 0:18 to 0:30 typography

President Trump made the case at a cabinet meeting: "It was $4 and $5 for a gallon of gas", he said, "and now it's probably 225".

Visual. Quote card, text only: the two quoted phrases appear as spoken; "225" holds and turns amber.

On screen. "It was $4 and $5 for a gallon of gas" / "and now it's probably 225"

Cite. Donald Trump at a cabinet meeting, via WRALDonald Trump at a cabinet meeting, via WRAL

5. sc05 · 0:30 to 0:37 typography

By this spring, CBS News was reporting pump prices "at their highest point since mid-2022".

Visual. Quote card, text only, mirrored from sc04; "highest point" turns red as it is spoken.

On screen. "at their highest point since mid-2022"

Cite. CBS News, spring 2026

6. sc06 · 0:37 to 0:60 data-chart

Here is the record to check them against: the Energy Information Administration's national monthly average for regular gas, in dollars not adjusted for inflation. From February 2021 through January 2025, it came to $3.46 a gallon, with a peak of $4.93 in June 2022.

Visual. Two tiles build in turn as each figure is spoken: the Biden-era average, then the June 2022 peak in red. The source line "EIA, nominal dollars" sits under the title from s06.

Average$3.4613.461usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 41-L56
Peak, June 2022$4.9294.929usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 41-L56

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

7. sc07 · 0:60 to 1:16 data-chart

In 2025 the lowest month, December, came to $2.89, well above the president's guess. Every month of 2025 was below the Biden-era average, but about level with the last months of his term.

Visual. Three tiles: December 2025 lands first on s08; then on s09 the Biden-era average and January 2025 (the last month of his term) join it, the last two close in size to show the level comparison.

Lowest 2025 month, December$2.8942.894usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L56
Biden-era average$3.4613.461usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L56
January 2025, Biden's last month$3.0763.076usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 44-L56

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

8. sc08 · 1:16 to 1:26 data-chart

Then the weekly price jumped, from $3.02 in the first week of March 2026 to $4.50 by mid-May.

Visual. Two tiles: the first week of March in neutral, then mid-May slamming in red on "$4.50".

First week of March$3.0153.015usdEIA regular gasoline, weekly, lines 467-L470
Mid-May$4.5004.5usdEIA regular gasoline, weekly, lines 467-L470

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, weekly average

9. sc09 · 1:26 to 1:44 typography

News reports tied the jump to the war with Iran: MS NOW said gas was "up by well over a dollar since the war started", and NBC News put it plainly: "it's the war in Iran that's largely causing fuel prices to rise".

Visual. Two quote lines, text only, each appearing as spoken: MS NOW's line first, NBC News's beneath it; "the war in Iran" turns amber.

On screen. "up by well over a dollar since the war started" / "it's the war in Iran that's largely causing fuel prices to rise"

Cite. MS NOWNBC News

10. sc10 · 1:44 to 1:54 data-chart

West Texas Intermediate crude oil jumped in the same month, from $64.51 a barrel in February to $91.38 in March.

Visual. Two tiles: February 2026 crude in neutral, March 2026 landing in red on "$91.38".

February 2026$64.5164.51usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52
March 2026$91.3891.38usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52

Cite. EIA, WTI crude oil, monthly average

11. sc11 · 1:54 to 2:05 typography

Those reports tie the rise to the war; the price record shows when prices jumped, but on its own it cannot rule out other causes.

Visual. One line sets centred: "Cannot rule out other causes"; "other causes" underlines as it is spoken.

On screen. Cannot rule out other causes

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, weekly average

12. sc12 · 2:05 to 2:13 typography

In October, President Trump made the same kind of claim about crude: "Oil was higher under Biden than it is under Trump".

Visual. Quote card, text only; "higher under Biden" turns amber as it is spoken.

On screen. "Oil was higher under Biden than it is under Trump"

Cite. Donald Trump, October 2026, via Right Side Broadcasting Network

13. sc13 · 2:13 to 2:31 data-chart

In September, the latest month in the EIA's crude table, it averaged $97 a barrel, higher than in every month of Biden's term except March through July 2022. Gas, meanwhile, averaged $4.36 a gallon in September.

Visual. Three tiles: September 2026 crude lands first, then the June 2022 crude peak beside it (higher), on "except March through July 2022"; on s16 the September 2026 gas tile joins in a separate colour, marked per gallon.

Crude, September 2026$97.3197.31usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52
Crude, June 2022$114.84114.84usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52
Gas, September 2026$4.3554.355usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 47-L56

Cite. EIA, WTI crude oil, monthly averageEIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

14. sc14 · 2:31 to 2:47 data-chart

Put the lines side by side and the pump price has moved with crude under both presidents: both peaked in June 2022, both ended 2025 lower than they started it, and both jumped in March 2026.

Visual. Four tiles in two columns, gas on the left and crude on the right: the June 2022 pair lands on "both peaked in June 2022", the March 2026 pair on "both jumped in March 2026". A render may draw the pairs as a dumbbell.

Gas, June 2022$4.9294.929usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 41-L56
Crude, June 2022$114.84114.84usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52
Gas, March 2026$3.6383.638usdEIA regular gasoline, monthly, lines 41-L56
Crude, March 2026$91.3891.38usdEIA WTI crude, monthly, lines 46-L52

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly averageEIA, WTI crude oil, monthly average

15. sc15 · 2:47 to 3:02 typography

That fits what a guest on PBS NewsHour said, that the pump price "is set in a global market"; but prices moving together cannot show that policy played no part, since policy can move crude itself.

Visual. Quote card, text only: the quoted phrase appears as spoken; "global market" turns amber; during the caveat the card dims slightly.

On screen. "is set in a global market"

Cite. Guest on PBS NewsHour

16. sc16 · 3:02 to 3:18 typography

So whether gas is cheaper than under Biden depends on the month: yes, against his term's average, through February 2026; no, in every month since March, though still short of that 2022 peak.

Visual. Two lines build: "Through February 2026: yes" in green, then "Since March: no" in red.

On screen. Through February 2026: yes / Since March: no

Cite. EIA, U.S. regular gasoline, monthly average

17. sc17 · 3:18 to 3:22 typography

But gas is one price among many. What about prices overall?

Visual. The question types on, centred.

On screen. What about prices overall?

18. sc18 · 3:22 to 3:30 typography

The channel Squirrelly Economics put the comparison this way: "Prices rose about 21% over Biden's 4 years".

Visual. Quote card, text only; "21%" holds and turns amber.

On screen. "Prices rose about 21% over Biden's 4 years"

Cite. Squirrelly Economics

19. sc19 · 3:30 to 3:47 typography

The Bureau of Labor Statistics' consumer price index agrees: it rose 21.4 percent from January 2021 to January 2025. From January 2025 to September 2026, the latest month, it rose 6.1 percent.

Visual. Two lines build, one per sentence: Biden's term total first, then this term so far, smaller numbers in a second colour.

On screen. January 2021 to January 2025: 21.4% / January 2025 to September 2026: 6.1%

Cite. BLS, consumer price index (CPI-U)

20. sc20 · 3:47 to 3:54 typography

But that sets a full term against one still under way, over a much shorter stretch.

Visual. One line sets large; "still under way" turns amber.

On screen. A full term against one still under way

21. sc21 · 3:54 to 4:14 typography

Over stretches as long as this one so far, at each end of Biden's term, prices rose 13.5 percent at the start, January 2021 to September 2022, and 4.5 percent at the end, May 2023 to January 2025.

Visual. Two lines build: the start of Biden's term, then the end, each landing on its figure.

On screen. January 2021 to September 2022: 13.5% / May 2023 to January 2025: 4.5%

Cite. BLS, consumer price index (CPI-U)

22. sc22 · 4:14 to 4:26 data-chart

And the count is still running: the year-on-year rate climbed from 2.4 percent in February 2026 to 3.7 percent in September, the same months gas jumped.

Visual. Two horizontal bars, February then September 2026, growing in as each figure is spoken; values printed at the bar ends.

February 20262.4%2.4percentBLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L99
September 20263.7%3.7percentBLS CPI, earnings and jobs series 2019-2026, lines 31-L99

Cite. BLS, consumer price index (CPI-U)

23. sc23 · 4:26 to 4:44 typography

So prices have risen more slowly this term than across Biden's term as a whole, though faster than in his last stretch, and by a smaller margin than the totals suggest; and the index cannot say how much of either rise any president caused.

Visual. Three lines build: "Slower than Biden's term as a whole" in green, "Faster than his last stretch" in red, then "Cause: not shown" in neutral.

On screen. Slower than Biden's term as a whole / Faster than his last stretch / Cause: not shown

Cite. BLS, consumer price index (CPI-U)

24. sc24 · 4:44 to 4:52 typography

Both answers turned on the calendar: which month counts as now, and how long a stretch you measure.

Visual. One line sets large; "calendar" holds and turns amber.

On screen. Both answers turned on the calendar

25. sc25 · 4:52 to 5:04 typography

So when someone tells you prices are lower, ask: compared with when, and over how long? And when the pump price moves, check what crude oil did that month.

Visual. Three short lines build: "Compared with when?", "Over how long?", then "What did crude do?".

On screen. Compared with when? / Over how long? / What did crude do?